PawnGuru

Pawn jewelry in Milwaukee: 5 jewelry shops.

5jewelry shops
4.2★avg rating
$50 to $5,000+typical loan
3% per monthWI max loan rate
Top picksHighest-rated of 5 jewelry shops
See all 5 jewelry shops belowBrowse all 6 pawn shops in Milwaukee

What gets the best offer

  • Gold and platinum pieces (priced by weight x karat x spot)
  • Diamond rings with GIA or IGI certificates
  • Branded designer pieces from Tiffany, Cartier, David Yurman
  • Vintage and estate pieces in original condition

What to bring

  • Government photo ID
  • Any appraisal papers, receipts, or certificates
  • Original box or pouch where possible
  • A clean, untangled piece (skip the polish; shops test the metal anyway)

Karat stamps and weight drive most offers. Loose stones with paperwork get the highest premiums. Plated pieces and costume jewelry rarely pawn for more than $20.

All 5 jewelry pawn shops in Milwaukee, WI

Sorted by rating and review count. Each listing accepts jewelry based on the shop's published specialties.

Pawn America

3.9 · 145 reviews

Pawn America's Milwaukee location on Lincoln Ave serves the south side with a large chain-store inventory and consistent service across electronics, tools, and jewelry.

electronicsjewelrytoolsgaming
(414) 546-7296 View details

Neighborhood Pawn & Resale

4.1 · 88 reviews

Rooted in Milwaukee's wholesale fur business since the 1950s, Neighborhood Pawn has grown into one of the Midwest's largest fur and leather distributors while providing community pawn services for over 60 years.

electronicsjewelrytoolsmusical instruments
(414) 763-7843 View details

Cash N Gold 2

4.3 · 0 reviews

Cash N Gold 2 in Milwaukee, Wisconsin.

electronicsgoldjewelrypawn loans
(414) 342-1100 View details

KNL Jewelry Shop

4.3 · 0 reviews

KNL Jewelry Shop in Milwaukee, Wisconsin.

jewelrygoldprecious metalspawn loans
(414) 339-8663 View details

1 more pawn shops in Milwaukee are not on this list. Some lend on jewelry occasionally, others stick to other categories. See the full city directory to compare every option.

Browse all 6 pawn shops in Milwaukee

Other categories in Milwaukee

gold 4

Pawning jewelry in Milwaukee, WI

How much can I get for jewelry at a Milwaukee pawn shop?
Typical jewelry loans in Milwaukee run $50 to $5,000+. The shop bases the offer on condition, brand, and resale demand. Karat stamps and weight drive most offers. Loose stones with paperwork get the highest premiums. Plated pieces and costume jewelry rarely pawn for more than $20.
What do I need to pawn jewelry in Milwaukee?
Bring a government photo ID and the item itself. For jewelry, also bring: Any appraisal papers, receipts, or certificates, Original box or pouch where possible, A clean, untangled piece (skip the polish; shops test the metal anyway).
How many Milwaukee pawn shops accept jewelry?
5 verified pawn shops in Milwaukee, WI list jewelry as a specialty in our directory. The list above is sorted by customer rating and review count, with the highest-rated shops at the top.
What is the maximum pawn loan rate in Wisconsin?
Wisconsin caps pawn loan rates at 3% per month. Minimum loan term: 90 days. Regulator: Wisconsin Department of Financial Institutions.

Last verified 2026-05-29. All 6 pawn shops in Milwaukee, WI · Pawn shops near me in Milwaukee

Sell or pawn smarter

Skip the drive. Get jewelry offers from Milwaukee shops.

List your jewelry once and verified Milwaukee pawn shops send private offers, usually within hours.

  • Free, no obligation
  • Your contact stays hidden
  • Offers in hours