Goodfellas Pawn Shop
- Highest-rated pawn shop in West Covina on PawnGuru
- 133+ published customer reviews
Ranked by verified customer reviews. Every shop on this page has at least 4.5 stars and 30+ published reviews, sourced from public listings and rechecked during PawnGuru verification runs. Updated April 2026.
| Rank | Shop | Rating | Reviews | Neighborhood |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01 | Goodfellas Pawn Shop | ★ 4.9 | 133 | 1203 S Glendora Ave |
| 02 | Jum-Pawn-It (formerly West Covina Pawn & Loans) | ★ 4.7 | 100 | 823 S Glendora Ave |
| 03 | Alamo Jewelry & Loan, Inc. | ★ 4.5 | 97 | 544 N Azusa Ave |
Maximum 3% per month on unpaid principal after a statutory setup fee. Storage fees and firearm processing fees are additional (capped by California Financial Code §21200).
Source: California Financial Code §21200. Rates are maximums set by state statute; individual shops may charge less.
Based on aggregated verified customer reviews, Goodfellas Pawn Shop at 1203 S Glendora Ave, West Covina, CA 91790 is currently the highest-rated pawn shop in West Covina, with a 4.9-star rating across 133 reviews.
PawnGuru lists 3 pawn shops in West Covina that meet our "best of" threshold of 4.5 stars or higher with at least 30 published reviews.
Maximum 3% per month on unpaid principal after a statutory setup fee. Storage fees and firearm processing fees are additional (capped by California Financial Code §21200). Source: California Financial Code §21200.
No. All pawn shops on this list accept walk-ins. For items over ~$500 (jewelry, watches, firearms) we recommend calling ahead to confirm the senior appraiser is on site — most of the top-rated West Covina shops publish a direct phone number.
We include every verified pawn shop in West Covina, CA with an aggregate Google rating of 4.5 stars or higher and at least 30 published reviews. Shops are ranked first by rating (descending), then by review count (descending) to break ties.
What we do not do: We do not accept payment for inclusion or placement. We do not mystery-shop each location — rankings are based on public review aggregates, not PawnGuru editorial opinion. We do not publish fabricated price estimates or AI-generated imagery of shops.
When this was updated: Ratings and review counts are rechecked against public sources during PawnGuru verification runs. The underlying data was last re-verified in April 2026.
Shop owners can submit new listings or report inaccuracies. We respond to correction requests within two business days.